Category Archives: Mountaineering

Already an extreme sport, mountaineering at high altitudes adds exponential risk! Know before you go!

Can I Ever Go Back Up To High Altitude Again? – Recurrence Risk of HAPE & HARPE

by Taylor Kligerman, PA-S

Can I ever return to high altitude? Do I need to move down to a lower elevation?

Disease processes often differ at high altitudes. Some conditions have only been known to occur at high elevations. Most of the resources cited in this blog refer to ‘high altitude’ being at or above 2,500 meters or 8,200 feet.

Ebert Family Clinic in Frisco, Colorado is at 9,075 ft. Many areas in the immediate vicinity are over 10,000′, with some patients living above 11,000′. Two of the more common conditions seen in patients at Ebert Family Clinic are high altitude pulmonary edema (HAPE) and high altitude resident pulmonary edema (HARPE), similar conditions that affect slightly different populations in this region of the Colorado Rocky Mountains.

In “classic” HAPE, a visitor may come from a low-altitude area to Frisco on a trip to ski with friends. On the first or second day, the person notices a nagging cough. They might wonder if they caught a virus on the plane ride to Denver. The cough is usually followed by shortness of breath that begins to make daily tasks overwhelmingly difficult. One of the dangerous aspects of HAPE is a gradual onset leading patients to believe their symptoms are caused by something else. A similar phenomenon is seen in re-entry HAPE, where a resident of a high altitude location travels to low altitude for a trip and upon return experiences these same symptoms [1].

In HARPE, a person living and working here in Frisco may be getting ill or slowly recovering from a viral illness and notices a worsening cough and fatigue. These cases are even more insidious, going unrecognized, and so treatment is sought very late. Dr. Christine Ebert-Santos and her team at Ebert Family Clinic hypothesize that while residents have adequately acclimated to the high-altitude environment, the additional lowering of blood oxygen due to a respiratory illness with inflammation may be the inciting event in these cases.

In both cases, symptoms are difficult to confidently identify as a serious illness versus an upper respiratory infection, or simply difficulty adjusting to altitude. For this reason, Dr. Chris recommends that everyone staying overnight at high altitude obtain a pulse oximeter. Many people became familiar with the use of these instruments during the COVID-19 pandemic. The pulse oximeter measures what percent of your blood is carrying oxygen. At high altitude, a healthy level of oxygenation is typically ≥90%. This is an easy way to both identify potential HAPE/HARPE, as well as reassure patients they are safely coping with the high-altitude environment [2].

HAPE and HARPE are both a direct result of hypobaric hypoxia, a lack of oxygen availability at altitude due to decreased atmospheric pressures. At certain levels of hypoxia, we observe a breakdown in the walls between blood vessels and the structures in lungs responsible for oxygenating blood. The process is still not totally understood, but some causes of this breakdown include an inadequate increase in breathing rates, reduced blood delivered to the lungs, reduced fluid being cleared from the lungs, and excessive constriction of blood vessels throughout the body. These processes cause fluid accumulation throughout the lungs in the areas responsible for gas exchange making it harder to oxygenate the blood [3].

We do know that genetics play a significant role in a person’s risk of developing HAPE/HARPE. Studies have proposed many different genes that may contribute, but research has not, so far, given healthcare providers a clear picture of which patients are most at-risk. Studies have shown that those at higher risk of pulmonary hypertension (high blood pressure in the blood vessels of your lungs), are more likely to develop HAPE [4]. This includes some types of congenital heart defects [5,6]. High blood pressures in the lungs reach a tipping point and appear to be the first event in this process. However, while elevated blood pressures in the lungs are essential for HAPE/HARPE, this by itself, does not cause the condition. The other ingredient necessary for HAPE/HARPE to develop is uneven tightening of the blood vessels in the lungs. When blood vessels are constricted locally, the blood flow is shifted mainly to the more open vessels, and this is where we primarily see fluid leakage. As the blood-oxygen barrier is broken down in these areas, we may also see hemorrhage in the air sacs of the lungs [3].

One observation healthcare providers and scientists have observed is that HAPE/HARPE can be rapidly reversed by either descending from altitude or using supplemental oxygen. Both strategies increase the availability of oxygen in the lungs, reducing the pressure on the lungs’ blood vessels by vasodilation, quickly improving the integrity of the blood-oxygen barrier.

In a preliminary review of over 100 cases of emergency room patients in Frisco diagnosed with hypoxemia (low blood oxygen content) Dr. Chris and her team have begun to see trends that suggest the availability of at-home oxygen markedly reduces the risk of a trip to the hospital. This demonstrates that patients with both at-home pulse oximeters and supplemental oxygen have the capability to notice possible symptoms of HAPE, assess their blood oxygen content, and apply supplemental oxygen if needed. This stops the development of HAPE/HARPE before damage is done in the lungs. In the case of many of our patients, these at-home supplies prevent emergencies and allow patients time to schedule an appointment with their primary care provider to better evaluate symptoms.

Additionally, Dr. Chris and her team have observed that patients with histories of asthma, cancer, pneumonia, and previous HAPE/HARPE are often better educated and alert to these early signs of hypoxia and begin treatment earlier on in the course of HAPE/HARPE, reducing the relative incidence identified by medical facilities. There are many reasons to seek emergent care such as low oxygen with a fever. Patients with other existing diseases causing chronically low oxygen such as chronic lung disease may not be appropriately treated with  supplemental oxygen, although this is a very small portion of the population. Discussions with healthcare providers on the appropriate prevention plan for each patient will help educate and prevent emergency care visits in both residents and visitors.

A young child with short brown hair and glasses with dark, round frames wears a nasal canula for oxygen.

Studies of larger populations have yet to be published. A review of the case reports in smaller populations suggests that the previously estimated recurrence rate of 60-80% is exaggerated. This is a significant finding as healthcare providers have relied on this recurrence rate to make recommendations to their patients who have been diagnosed with HAPE. A review of 21 cases of children in Colorado diagnosed with HAPE reported that 42% experienced at least one recurrence [7]. This study was conducted by voluntary completion of a survey by the patients (or their families) which could lead to significant participation bias affecting the results. Patients more impacted by HAPE are more likely to complete these surveys. Another study looking at three cases of gradual re-ascent following an uncomplicated HAPE diagnosis showed no evidence of recurrence. The paper also suggested there may be some remodeling of the lung anatomy after an episode of HAPE that helps protect a patient from reoccurrence [8]. Similar suggestions of remodeling have been proposed through evidence of altitude being a protective factor in preventing death as demonstrated by fatality reports from COVID-19[9].

Without larger studies and selection of participants to eliminate other variables like preexisting diseases, we are left to speculate on the true rate of reoccurrence based on the limited information we have. Strategies to reduce the risk of HAPE/HARPE such as access to supplemental oxygen, pulse oximeters, and prescription medications [10] are the best way to prevent HAPE/HARPE. Research should also continue to seek evidence of individuals most at risk for developing HAPE/HARPE [11].

A woman with reddish-brown, straight hair just below her shoulders, wears a white coat over a mustard-colored shirt, smiling.
  1. Ucrós S, Aparicio C, Castro-Rodriguez JA, Ivy D. High altitude pulmonary edema in children: A systematic review. Pediatr Pulmonol. 2023;58(4):1059-1067. doi:10.1002/ppul.26294
  2. Deweber K, Scorza K. Return to activity at altitude after high-altitude illness. Sports Health. 2010;2(4):291-300. doi:10.1177/1941738110373065
  3. Bärtsch P. High altitude pulmonary edema. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1999;31(1 Suppl):S23-S27. doi:10.1097/00005768-199901001-00004
  4. Eichstaedt C, Benjamin N, Grünig E. Genetics of pulmonary hypertension and high-altitude pulmonary edema. J Appl Physiol. 2020;128:1432
  5. Das BB, Wolfe RR, Chan K, Larsen GL, Reeves JT, Ivy D. High-Altitude Pulmonary Edema in Children with Underlying Cardiopulmonary Disorders and Pulmonary Hypertension Living at Altitude. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2004;158(12):1170–1176. doi:10.1001/archpedi.158.12.1170
  6. Liptzin DR, Abman SH, Giesenhagen A, Ivy DD. An Approach to Children with Pulmonary Edema at High Altitude. High Alt Med Biol. 2018;19(1):91-98. doi:10.1089/ham.2017.0096
  7. Kelly TD, Meier M, Weinman JP, Ivy D, Brinton JT, Liptzin DR. High-Altitude Pulmonary Edema in Colorado Children: A Cross-Sectional Survey and Retrospective Review. High Alt Med Biol. 2022;23(2):119-124. doi:10.1089/ham.2021.0121
  8. Litch JA, Bishop RA. Reascent following resolution of high altitude pulmonary edema (HAPE). High Alt Med Biol. 2001;2(1):53-55. doi:10.1089/152702901750067927
  9. Gerken J, Zapata D, Kuivinen D, Zapata I. Comorbidities, sociodemographic factors, and determinants of health on COVID-19 fatalities in the United States. Front Public Health. 2022;10:993662. Published 2022 Nov 3. doi:10.3389/fpubh.2022.993662
  10. Luks A, Swenson E, Bärtsch P. Acute high-altitude sickness. European Respiratory Review. 2017;26: 160096; DOI: 10.1183/16000617.0096-2016
  11. Dehnert C, Grünig E, Mereles D, von Lennep N, Bärtsch P. Identification of individuals susceptible to high-altitude pulmonary oedema at low altitude. European Respiratory Journal 2005;25(3):545-551; DOI: 10.1183/09031936.05.00070404

Doc Talk: Physician Altitude Experts on High Altitude Pulmonary Edema (HAPE)

One of our students recently came across a comprehensive publication on high altitude pulmonary edema (HAPE) on reputable point-of-care clinical resource UpToDate.com1, citing Christine Ebert-Santos, MD, MPS, the founder of highaltitudehealth.com.

Emergency medicine physician at Aspen Valley Hospital and medical director for Mountain Rescue Aspen since 1997 Dr. Scott A. Gallagher2 and emergency physician and altitude research pioneer Dr. Peter Hackett3 introduce the resource warning, “Anyone who travels to high altitude, whether a recreational hiker, skier, mountain climber, soldier, or worker, is at risk of developing high-altitude illness.”

Ebert-Santos’s (known affectionately to her patients and mountain community as “Dr. Chris”) own research is referenced in the article’s discussion of epidemiology and risk factors noting an additional category of HAPE among “children living at altitude who develop pulmonary edema with respiratory infection but without change in altitude,”4 whereas the two other recognized categories (classic HAPE and re-entry HAPE) typically happen in response to a change in altitude.

The article continues with figures illustrating how ascending too quickly or too much can dramatically increase risk: “HAPE generally occurs above 2500 meters (8000 feet) and is uncommon below 3000 meters (10,000 feet) … The risk depends upon individual susceptibility, altitude attained, rate of ascent, and time spent at high altitude. in those without a history of HAPE, the incidence is 0.2 percent with ascent to 4500 meters (14,800 feet) over four days but 6 percept when ascent occurs over one to two days. In those with a history of HAPE, recurrence is 60 percent with an ascent to 4500 meters over two days. At 5500 meters (18,000 feet), the incidence ranges between 2 and 15 percent, again depending upon rate of ascent.”

Dr. Chris discusses her experience treating her pediatric patients at high altitude in more depth in an interview with pediatric emergency medicine physician Dr. Alison Brent from Colorado Children’s Hospital for the podcast Charting Pediatrics.

Dr. Gallagher and Dr. Hackett’s article is available on UpToDate with a subscription.

  1. https://www.uptodate.com/contents/high-altitude-pulmonary-edema?source=autocomplete&index=0~1&search=HAPE ↩︎
  2. https://www.aspenhospital.org/people/scott-a-gallagher-md/ ↩︎
  3. https://www.highaltitudedoctor.org/dr-peter-hackett ↩︎
  4. Ebert-Santos, C. High-Altitude Pulmonary Edema in Mountain Community Residents. High Alt Med Biol 2017; 18:278. ↩︎

Interview with Dr. Christine Ebert-Santos on High Altitude Pulmonary Edema

by Cody Jones, Summit Daily News

“‘The first sign is usually a cough,’ Ebert-Santos said. ‘Followed by shortness of breath with any effort — even just walking — and fatigue. You just want to lie on the couch.’

If left untreated the early warning signs of high altitude pulmonary edema can rapidly progress into having fluid build up in the lungs, which will then lead to a patient’s oxygen saturation levels rapidly decreasing. If the individual does not seek treatment quickly, the condition can be fatal.”

Read the whole article here.

The Impact of High Altitude on Diabetes Diagnosis: The Relationship between Hemoglobin A1c and Fasting Plasma Glucose

Type 2 Diabetes (T2D) has emerged as a global concern, with its prevalence steadily increasing. The test of choice to diagnose and monitor T2D is hemoglobin A1c (HbA1c), which tracks average blood sugar levels over the last three months. Normal HbA1c levels are below 5.7%, 5.7% to 6.4% indicates prediabetes, and 6.5% or higher indicates diabetes. Within the prediabetes range, high HbA1c levels increase the risk of developing T2D. Additionally, levels above 6.5% correlate with greater risk for diabetes complications.1 Fasting Plasma Glucose (FPG) is an additional test that indicates an immediate blood sugar level following a period of fasting. Normal FPG levels are below 100 mg/dL (5.5 mmol/L), 100 to 125 mg/dL (5.6 to 6.9 mmol/L) suggests prediabetes, whereas 126 mg/dL (7 mmol/L) or higher generally indicates diabetes.2 Because HbA1c provides an overview of blood sugar levels spanning the past 2-3 months, it offers a more comprehensive insight into blood sugar management and is the preferred diagnostic test for T2D.3 Recent studies are unveiling discrepancies between HbA1c and glucose testing, prompting discussions on specific diagnostic criteria for different populations.

People living at high altitude experience unique physiological adaptations, such as higher hemoglobin levels and specific glucose metabolism patterns. Acknowledging these adaptations, a 2017 study by Bazo-Alvarez et. al sought to evaluate the relationship between HbA1c and FPG among individuals at sea level compared to those at high altitude.

The study analyzed data from 3613 Peruvian adults without diagnosed diabetes from both sea level and high altitude (>3000m). The mean values for hemoglobin, HbA1c, and FPG differed significantly between these populations. The correlation between HbA1c and FPG was quadratic at sea level but linear at high altitude, suggesting different glucose metabolism patterns. Additionally, for an HbA1c value of 48 mmol/mol (6.5%), corresponding mean FPG values were significantly different: 6.6 mmol/l at sea level versus 14.8 mmol/l at high altitude.

Tall, snowy mountain peaks rise in the distance over rows of deep green pine trees growing out of the hills around a bike. path in the foreground.

This significant difference in predictive values suggests potential controversy in utilizing HbA1c as a diagnostic tool for diabetes in high altitude settings. Using HbA1c at altitude potentially underdiagnoses and under treats patients. To ensure a more accurate diagnosis of T2D at high altitude, reevaluating diagnostic criteria, possibly leaning towards FPG or oral glucose tolerance testing (OGTT) might be necessary.

In conclusion, this study emphasizes the need for careful consideration when diagnosing diabetes in high-altitude regions. Future research is warranted, including studies replicating the findings of the cross-sectional study by Bazo-Alvarez and longitudinal studies exposing the long-term effects of the diagnostic discrepancy of HbA1c in high altitude patients. This additional data will ensure accurate diagnosis and appropriate management of diabetic patients at high altitude.

  1. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. A1C Test. Accessed 12/26/23. Available from: https://www.cdc.gov/diabetes/managing/managing-blood-sugar/a1c.html
  2. World Health Organization. Fasting Blood Glucose. Accessed 12/26/23. Available from: https://www.who.int/data/gho/indicator-metadata-registry/imr-details/2380#:~:text=When%20fasting%20blood%20glucose%20is,separate%20tests%2C%20diabetes%20is%20diagnosed   
  3. Sherwani, S.I., et al. 2016. Significance of HbA1c Test in Diagnosis and Prognosis of Diabetic Patients. Biomark. Insights. 2016 Jul; 11: 95-104. DOI: 10.4137/BMI.S38440.
  4. Bazo-Alvarez, J. C., et al. Glycated haemoglobin (HbA1c) and fasting plasma glucose relationships in sea-level and high-altitude settings. Diabet. Med. 2017 Jun; 34(6): 804-812. DOI: 10.1111/dme.13335.

What is Acute Mountain Sickness?

Acute mountain sickness (AMS) is a condition that can occur when individuals ascend to high altitudes rapidly, typically above 2,500 meters (8,200 feet). The symptoms of AMS are due to the body’s struggle to adapt to the decreased oxygen levels at higher elevations. More specifically, the symptoms are caused by cerebral vasodilation that occurs in response to hypoxia, in an attempt to maintain cerebral perfusion.1

The typical symptoms of AMS include headache, nausea, vomiting, anorexia, and fatigue. In children the symptoms are less specific including increased fussiness, crying, poor feeding, disrupted sleep, and vomiting. Symptom onset is usually 6-12 hours after arrival to altitude but this can vary.

AMS affects children, adults, males and females equally, with a slight increased incidence in females. It is difficult to believe, but physical fitness does not offer protection against AMS. However, people who are obese, live at low elevation, or undergo intense activities upon arrival to elevation are at increased risk.1

Descending

Descending and decreasing altitude is a vital treatment for people with severe symptoms of AMS. By decreasing altitude there will be more oxygen in the air and symptoms will not be as severe..2 

Oxygen

Since the main cause of AMS is hypoxia, oxygen supplementation is an effective treatment when descent is not wanted or possible. Supplemental oxygen even at .5L to 1L per hour can be effective in reducing symptoms.It can be prescribed for short periods of time or to be used only during sleep  In the central Colorado Rockies, this may be a practical solution for “out of towners” who have traveled up to the town of Leadville (10,158’/3096m) for vacation, but in an austere environment supplemental oxygen may not be a reasonable treatment option. There should be symptomatic improvement within one hour.

Acetazolamide

Acetazolamide is a carbonic anhydrase inhibitor which causes increased secretion of sodium, potassium, bicarb, and water. This mechanism of actions lends beneficial to the treatment of AMS because it decreases the carbonic anhydrase in the brain. 3There is evidence to support the use of acetazolamide in the prevention of AMS, but minimal evidence pointing towards it’s role in treatment. Dosing is inconsistent but is usually prescribed at 125-250mg BID.

Hyperbaric Therapy

Many people consider hyperbaric chambers to be large structures in hospitals, however there are portable and lightweight hyperbaric chambers that can be used in austere environments or during expeditions. The mechanism of action of hyperbaric therapy is a simulated decrease in elevation, of approximately 2500 meters. These chambers will remove symptoms within approximately one hour of use but symptoms are likely to return. They are useful in the field but not frequently required in a hospital setting.1

  1. https://www.uptodate.com/contents/acute-mountain-sickness-and-high-altitude-cerebral-edema?search=acute%20mountain%20sickness&source=search_result&selectedTitle=1~15&usage_type=default&display_rank=1#H35
  2. https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/15111-altitude-sickness
  3. https://www.uptodate.com/contents/acetazolamide-drug-information?search=acetazolamide%20altitude&source=search_result&selectedTitle=2~150&usage_type=default&display_rank=2#F129759

Lightning Strikes in Colorado

My love for hiking developed during my childhood explorations of the breathtaking landscapes of the Sierra Nevada. As I ventured into the rugged mountains and hiked along scenic trails, I couldn’t help but feel a deep connection with nature. However, my passion for hiking was not without its moments of caution. On several occasions, I witnessed the awe-inspiring yet intimidating power of lightning storms dancing across the vast mountain skies. These encounters instilled in me a profound curiosity about the risks associated with lightning strikes in high-altitude regions.

When I moved to Colorado for PA school, my awareness of the dangers posed by lightning strikes grew even stronger. The dramatic topography and frequent thunderstorms in Colorado amplify the risk for individuals exploring high-altitude areas. It was during my last clinical rotation at a burn unit that I had the opportunity to care for several patients who had been struck by lightning. Witnessing the effects firsthand fueled my determination to educate the public about the actionable steps they can take to stay safe during lightning storms.

Lightning strikes

​Lightning possesses an immense amount of energy, with a voltage of over 10 million volts (in comparison, most car batteries measure 12.6 V).1 Additionally, a lightning bolt reaches incredibly high temperatures, reportedly up to 30,000 Kelvin (53540.33 F).1 Lightning injuries occur in different ways, including as direct strikes, side splash, contact injuries, or ground current. 

Direct strikes are uncommon, accounting for only 5% of cases, and happen when a person is directly struck by lightning.2

Contact injuries occur when a person touches an object that is struck by lightning. 2

Side splash injuries occur when the current jumps or “splashes” from a nearby object and then follows the path of least resistance to reach the individual. These injuries make up about 1/3 of all lightning related injuries. 2

Ground current is the most prevalent cause of injury, accounting for half of all cases, and occurs when lightning strikes an object or the ground near a person and subsequently travels through the ground to reach the individual. 2

In Colorado, an average of 500,000 lightning flashes hit the ground each year. Based on data since 1980, lightning causes 2 fatalities and 12 injuries per year throughout the state.3According to data since 1980, lightning causes an average of 2 fatalities and 12 injuries annually throughout the state. 3 Colorado ranked third in the United States for the number of lightning fatalities between 2005 and 2014, as depicted in Figure 1.

Fig. 1. Lightning fatalities by state. 3

The high number of injuries attributed to lightning in Colorado can be influenced by several factors. One of these factors is the easy access to high elevation terrain, such as 14ers (mountains with a peak elevation of at least 14,000 feet). This accessibility allows inexperienced outdoor enthusiasts to venture into potentially dangerous situations due to their lack of knowledge and preparation.

For instance, individuals who are not familiar with summer weather patterns may embark on a hike above the tree line late in the day, underestimating the risk of a storm forming. This lack of understanding puts them in an exposed and perilous position should adverse weather conditions arise.

Even with thorough preparation and extensive knowledge of weather patterns, it is still possible to find oneself in a situation where you have to weather a storm. Given that a significant proportion of Colorado’s hiking trails are located above the tree line, where appropriate shelter is sparse, hikers are more susceptible to lightning strikes in these exposed areas. 

Pathophysiology of Lightning Strike Injuries

The overall ratio of lightning injuries to deaths is 10:1 and there is a 90% chance of sequelae in survivors.4 The primary mechanism of injury in lightning strikes is the passage of electrical current through the body. The high voltage and current can cause tissue damage through several mechanisms, including thermal injury, electrical burns, and mechanical disruption of tissues. The severity of the injury depends on factors such as the voltage and current of the lightning bolt, the duration of contact, and the pathway the current takes through the body.

Lightning strikes can cause various types of injuries, with cardiac and respiratory arrest being the most common fatal complications.5 The path of least resistance determines the flow of electricity through different organs in the body, with nerves being the most conductive, followed by blood, muscles, skin, fat, and bone. 5 When lightning strikes, the electrical surge can induce cardiac arrest and cessation of breathing by affecting the medullary respiratory center. As a result, most patients initially present with asystole and may progress to different types of arrhythmias, commonly ventricular fibrillation. 5

Interestingly, there have been case reports documenting successful resuscitation of lightning strike victims who were initially apneic and pulseless for as long as 15 to 30 minutes. 5This has led to the recommendation that in the immediate aftermath of a lightning strike, individuals who appear to be dead should be prioritized for treatment.

Superficial skin burns are experienced by around 90% of lightning strike victims, but deep burns are less common, occurring in less than 5% of cases. A characteristic skin manifestation of a lightning strike is the Lichtenberg figure, which is considered pathognomonic. Neurological symptoms can also occur, including keraunoparalysis, which is a transient paralysis affecting the lower limbs more than the upper limbs. This paralysis is often accompanied by sensory loss, paleness, vasoconstriction, and hypertension, and is thought to result from overstimulation of the autonomic nervous system, leading to vascular spasm. In most cases, this paralysis resolves within several hours, but in some instances, it may last up to 24 hours or cause permanent neurological damage. 5

Additionally, it is common for lightning strike victims to have a perforated tympanic membrane (eardrum) or develop cataracts immediately following the incident. These injuries to the ear and eyes are associated with the intense energy of the lightning discharge. 6

What can hikers do to stay safe?

Preparation

Monitor weather forecasts: Stay updated on weather conditions before engaging in outdoor activities, especially in areas prone to thunderstorms. Pay attention to thunderstorm warnings or watches issued by local authorities. Having a mobile or handheld NOAA Weather Radio All-Hazards (NWR) can also be helpful as it can transmit life-saving weather information at a moment’s notice. 

In Colorado most thunderstorms develop after 11 am, so it is best to plan your trip so that you are descending by late morning.7 Fig. 2 shows number of lightning fatalities by time of day in Colorado between 1980 and 2020. The vast majority take place after the 11 am threshold.

Fig. 2  Lightning fatalities in Colorado by time of day3

What to Do If Caught in a Storm

If you can hear thunder, you are close enough to be struck by lightning. Lightning can strike up to 25 miles away from the storm. 7 Once you hear thunder, if possible quickly move to a sturdy shelter (substantial building with electricity or plumbing or an enclosed, metal-topped vehicle with windows up). Avoid small shelters, such as picnic pavilions, tents, or sheds. Stay sheltered until at least 30 minutes after you hear the last clap of thunder.

Fig 3. Areas to avoid when sheltering from lightning.

If you are outdoors and cannot reach a suitable shelter, avoid open areas, hilltops, and high places that are more exposed to lightning strikes. Seek lower ground and stay away from tall objects, such as trees, poles, or metal structures. Bodies of water, including lakes, rivers, pools, and even wet ground, are conductive and increase the risk of a lightning strike. Move away from these areas during thunderstorms. Separate group members by at least 20 ft as lightning can jump up to 15 feet between objects.

​If a strike is eminent (static electricity causes hair or skin to stand on end, a smell of ozone is detected, a crackling sound is heard nearby), the current recommendation is to assume “lightning position”, pictured in Fig. 4.

Fig. 4. Lightning position8

To potentially reduce the risk of ground current injury from an imminent lightning strike, another strategy is to insulate oneself from the ground. This can be done by sitting on a pack or a rolled foam sleeping pad. However, it’s important to note that this and the lightning position should be considered a strategy of last resort and not relied upon as the primary means of prevention. Maintaining this position for an extended period can be challenging, and it’s crucial to prioritize seeking proper shelter and following established lightning safety guidelines to minimize the overall risk of injury. 5

Case Study

25 YO F presents to the Burn Unit as a transfer from Cheyenne Regional Medical Center s/p lighting strike. Patient (pt) was caught in a thunderstorm on a hike and sheltered under a tall tree. Suddenly, she felt like she was being lifted up into the air and then dropped. Pt had a brief (<5 sec) loss of consciousness (LOC). When she woke up, she was completely numb and couldn’t move any of her extremities. Witness (friend) states the lightning splashed from the tree to the pt. Pt denies hitting her head with the fall. She denies taking blood thinners. She has no past medical history (PMHx) or past surgical history (PSHx).

Physical exam 

Neuro: AOX4, No CN deficit on exam, LE paralysis resolved, LE paresthesia improving but still present

HEENT: L ruptured tympanic membrane, hearing loss on L side

CV: RRR

MSK: Soft compartments diffusely

Skin: Lichtenberg figures on bilateral LE 

Fig. 6. Lichtenberg figure on LLE

V/S: BP: 128/92, HR: 96, RR:18, SPO2: 98%, Temp 98.1F. 

CBC, CMP, troponin were all WNL. Serum hCG negative. CK mildly elevated (222) 

EKG showed NSR.

CXR, CT brain, and c-spine neg for acute injury

She was admitted to the UC Health burn center for observation with tele. Her lab work and vitals remained stable throughout her hospitalization. She was evaluated by the trauma team with a negative trauma work up. The day of discharge, she was tolerating a regular diet, ambulating and sating well on room air. She was deemed appropriate for discharge home without patient audiology and ophthalmology follow up. 

References

1. US Department of Commerce N. Understanding lightning science. National Weather Service. April 16, 2018. Accessed July 8, 2023. https://www.weather.gov/safety/lightning-science-overview. 

2. Cooper MA, Holle RL. Mechanisms of lightning injury should affect lightning safety messages. 21st International Lightning Detection Conference. April 19-20, 2010; Orlando, FL. 

3. US Department of Commerce N. Colorado Lightning statistics as compared to other states. National Weather Service. March 4, 2020. Accessed July 7, 2023.https://www.weather.gov/pub/Colorado_ltg_ranking. 

4. US Department of Commerce N. How dangerous is lightning? National Weather Service. March 12, 2019. Accessed July 8, 2023. https://www.weather.gov/safety/lightning-odds. 

5. Chris Davis, MD; Anna Engeln, MD; Eric L. Johnson, MD; Scott E. McIntosh, MD, MPH; Ken Zafren, MD; Arthur A. Islas, MD, MPH; Christopher McStay, MD; William R. Smith, MD; Tracy Cushing, MD, MPH. Wilderness Medical Society Practice Guidelines for the Prevention and Treatment of Lightning Injuries: 2014 Update. WILDERNESS & ENVIRONMENTAL MEDICINE. 2014; 25, S86–S95 

6. Flaherty G, Daly J. When lightning strikes: reducing the risk of injury to high-altitude trekkers during thunderstorms. Academic.oup.com. Accessed July 8, 2023. https://academic.oup.com/jtm/article/23/1/tav007/2635599. 

7. NWS Colorado Offices – Boulder G. Colorado Lightning Awareness Week june 19-25, 2022. ArcGIS StoryMaps. June 25, 2022. Accessed July 8, 2023. https://storymaps.arcgis.com/stories/11d021f1b800429a869ead2dc32c0f96. 

8. McKay B and K. How to survive A lightning strike: An illustrated guide. The Art of Manliness. April 25, 2022. Accessed July 8, 2023. https://www.artofmanliness.com/skills/outdoor-survival/how-to-survive-a-lightning-strike-an-illustrated-guide/. 

A woman with long, light brown hair over her shoulders wearing a blue, sleeveless shirt with red details smiles with blue eyes.

Sophia Ruef is a Physician Assistant student at Red Rocks Community College in Arvada, CO. She grew up on the central coast of California and earned her Bachelor of Science degree inBiology with a concentration in anatomy and physiology from Cal Poly San Luis Obispo. She worked as an EMT and a tech in the Bay Area after her undergraduate education. In her free time, she enjoys hiking, backpacking, canyoneering, and spending time with family and friends.

Mountain People Can Still Get Mountain Sickness: HL-HAPE, a Fourth Type of High Altitude Pulmonary Edema

There are three types of High Altitude Pulmonary Edema (HAPE) recognized in visitors and people living at high altitudes. These include classic HAPE (C-HAPE), which involves an individual that lives at low altitude traveling to high altitude. Re-entry HAPE (RE-HAPE)  is seen in an individual that lives at high altitude who travels to low altitude and then returns to high altitude. And high-altitude resident pulmonary edema (HARPE) which occurs in an individual that lives at high altitude and does not change altitude (Ebert-Santos, Wiley). While these have been extensively studied and are subtypes that people are warned of, a fourth unexpected type of HAPE has been recently described by pediatric pulmonologist Santiago Ucros in Bogota, Columbia at the Universidad de los Andes. (Ucros)

Highlanders HAPE (HL-HAPE) occurs in people that live at high altitude who then travel to higher altitudes. Though most people who live at high altitudes for long periods of time assume they are immune to HAPE, the recognition of HL-HAPE shows this is not the case. One man had a run-in with HL-HAPE during his long-awaited trip to Mt. Kilimanjaro. 

A man wearing a neck gator under a grey baseball cap and dressed in cold-weather jacket and pants sits on a rock next to a tall giant groundsel plant with cushions of dead leaves puffing up heads of light-green leaves before the sloping of the mountain down into a valley with a white cloud floating above it.

A resident of Summit County, Colorado, Jonathan Huffman set out to climb Mt. Kilimanjaro with his wife Katie when he was 37 years old. He is originally from Texas, but has been living in Breckenridge, Colorado, elevation 9,600 ft, for 15 years. In preparation for the climb, he spent the summer hiking multiple fourteen thousand foot peaks in Colorado, trail running at 9,000-12,000 ft, and mountain biking. 

Two people stand smiling toward the camera with an arm around each other, dressed warmly in long pants, thick jackets and hats, one holding a water bottle, standing on an open field of high alpine shrubs with Mt. Kilimanjaro illuminated in the pink light of the sun, streaked with long, narrow clouds in the background

The elevation of Mt. Kilimanjaro is 19,341 feet and the summit generally takes each group anywhere from 5 to 9 days, depending on the route taken. In September, Jonathan and Katie traveled to Tanzania where they spent two days adjusting to jet lag and preparing for their climb. They had chosen to follow the Lemosho Route which is 42 miles long with an elevation gain of 16,000 to 17,000 feet. 

On the first day, Jonathan and his party started at the Lemosho trailhead (7,742 feet) and hiked up 9,498 feet to the first camp. He noticed that his throat felt dry and he found himself having to clear it often. He attributed this symptom to the dusty environment. 

On the second day, he felt as though his body was fighting the dust, which had found its way into his eyes, sinuses, and throat. He also felt extremely fatigued and stated that every action felt more difficult. Though he could tell his body was struggling to adapt, Jonathan continued to push forward with full force. He made it to the second camp at 11,500 feet. 

A group of orange and white panelled tents sit in the shade of a rocky mountain peak streaked with snow, illuminated in sun above the camp against a cloudless blue sky.

“Day three, we went from 11,500 feet to 13,800 feet,” Jonathan recounts. “After we arrived to this camp, our guides offered to allow us to take a break then hike even higher. This was [an] optional acclimatization test … but I actually skipped it. I was so tired when I got to camp on this day, I decided to just nap in the tent until dinner time.”

On the fourth day, Jonathan’s group hiked up an overpass to Lava Tower located at 15,190 feet. This was also an altitude test, and he passed. He stated that this was the highest he had ever climbed, but that he was beginning to feel more like his normal self. The group stopped for lunch at the tower, but he did not have much of an appetite. He ate the food anyways at the insistence of the guides. 

A sea of clouds illuminated in blues and soft pinks stretches out behind several tents pitched over a shaded, rocky mountain slope in the foreground.

“Then after lunch, we descended down to Barranco Camp [from 15,190 feet to 13,044 feet] and this is where I realized I had HAPE.”

As they were nearing the camp, he felt fluid building in his lungs that was easy to cough up. By the evening, however, he felt as though he was drowning and was unable to lay down. While the guides encouraged him to immediately hike down, he did not want to hike in the dark. He spent the night propped up on duffle bags or sitting in a kitchen chair, with his oxygen reaching as low as 67% at one point. 

Two people sit in the dark of a tent, one with an oxygen mask on and a red head lamp illuminating tin food containers and medical supplies in the foreground as he is administered oxygen.

In the morning, he received 30 minutes of oxygen treatment before beginning his 8-hour descent. His symptoms improved when he reached 6,500 feet. He was picked up in a rescue vehicle and received further treatment at a hospital in Moshi. While he made a full recovery, he stated that he still felt the effects of HAPE while exercising in Colorado at times, up to months after the experience. While Jonathan was only about 2 days away from the summit, he knew that turning back was the best choice. He plans to re-attempt the climb in a few years. 

Jonathan’s story serves as an important reminder to those living at altitude that HAPE can affect anyone. Jonathan’s wife Katie along with everyone else in the group also experienced mild symptoms of altitude sickness including headaches. Research still needs to be conducted on the cause and prevention of this condition in all types. While this shouldn’t stop hikers and climbers from climbing mountains, they should be aware of the signs and symptoms of HAPE, when to seek treatment, and the best ways to prevent it from occurring. 

A map of the Lemosho route as listed on the Ultimate Kilimanjaro guide site can be found here.

A group of people in bright colored pants, jackets and backpacks make their way down a red dirt trail surrounded by tall green grasses and trees extending over a white SUV with a red cross symbol on it in the background down the road.
A man in a beige baseball cap takes a selfie with three men in hats and jackets behind him smiling toward the camera with a white jeep labelled with a red cross in the background behind them.

HAFE: High-Altitude Flatus Expulsion

Often, at high altitude we hear complaints of gas pain and increased flatus in our infant population. Parents often wonder, are we doing something wrong? Is my child reacting to breastmilk, or showing an intolerance to certain foods?  Actually there is another explanation for increased flatus and gas pain in the high-altitude region of Colorado. 

The term HAFE was coined by Dr. Paul Auerbach and Dr. York Miller and published in the Western Journal of Medicine in 1981. Their discovery began In the summer of 1980, when the two doctors were hiking in the San Juan Mountains of Colorado on a quest to summit three 14ers. During their ascent they noticed that something didn’t smell right! As the pair continued to emit noxious fumes, they began to put their scientific brains to work and discovered HAFE. The symptoms include an increase in frequency and volume of flatus, or in other terms an increase in toots! We all have familiarity in watching our bag of potato chips blow up when reaching altitude or our water bottle expanding as we head into the mountains. This reaction is due to a decrease in barometric pressure. Based on Boyle’s law, decreased barometric pressure causes the intestinal gas volume to expand, thus causing HAFE (Skinner & Rawal, 2019).

A graphic illustrating how Boyle's law works: the pressure of a gas increases as its volume decreases.

To my surprise, a gas bubble the size of a walnut in Denver, Colorado (5280 ft) would be the size of a grapefruit in the mountain region of Summit County, CO (8000+ ft)! Trapped gas is known to lead to discomfort and pain. The use of simethicone may have merit in mitigating the effects of HAFE. Simethicone works by changing the surface tension of gas bubbles, allowing easier elimination of gas. This medication, while benign, can be found over the counter and does not appear to be absorbed by the GI tract (Ingold, C. J., & Akhondi, H., 2022). 

While this phenomenon may not be as debilitating as high-altitude pulmonary edema (HAPE), it deserves recognition, as it can cause a significant inconvenience and discomfort to those it inflicts. As the Radiolab podcast explained in their episode The Flight Before Christmas , expelled gas in a plane or car when driving up to the mountains can be embarrassing. While HAFE can be inconvenient, it is a benign condition and a matter of pressure changes rather than a disease or pathological process. We would love to talk more about HAFE at Ebert Family Clinic if you have any questions or concerns!

A bald eagle flies over a misty settled into the valley against the blue-green pine forest of a mountain.
A bald eagle flies toward its nest atop a bare lodgepole pine.

As always, stay happy, safe, and healthy 😊

References

Auerbach, P. & Miller, Y. (1981). High altitude flatus expulsion. The Western Journal of Medicine, 134(2), 173-174.

Chemistry Learner. (2023). Boyle’s Law. https://www.chemistrylearner.com/boyles-law.html

Ingold, C. J., & Akhondi, H. (2022). Simethicone. StatPearls Publishing. 

McKnight, T. (2023). The Flight Before Christmas [Audio podcast]. Radiolab. https://radiolab.org/episodes/flight-christmas

Skinner, R. B., & Rawal, A. R. (2019). EMS flight barotrauma. StatPearls Publishing. 

When Altitude gets High, does Stroke get higher?

Does altitude increase or decrease risk of strokes? As one review put it, “Due to limited literature, lack of large series, and controlled studies, the understanding of stroke at high altitude is still sketchy and incomplete”. What is clear is that stroke at high altitude can often be misdiagnosed (or underdiagnosed), due to the similarity of initial presentation with high altitude cerebral edema (HACE). Both conditions present with imbalance or ataxia, and both can present with focal neurological deficits.  There are few large urban populations at high altitude (Addis Ababa in Ethiopia is 7,726 ft), so medical providers have fewer resources.  Without the ability to perform neuroimaging with a CT scan or MRI in a timely manner a diagnosis of HACE vs. stroke could be uncertain. HACE often causes global cerebral dysfunction, differentiating it from an early stroke before the onset of focal symptoms can and often does prove challenging. 

While the prevalence of strictly hemorrhagic and ischemic strokes at high altitude remains murky, it is known that exposure to high altitude can result in conditions such as TIA, cerebral venous thrombosis (CVT), seizures, and cranial nerve palsies. Most of the research that has been done on strokes is focused on “moderate” and “high” altitudes, as opposed to “very high” or “extremely high” altitudes. As such, there is very little research on populations living at 3500m or higher. There was at least one tangible piece of evidence indicating that the higher the elevation, the earlier the mean onset of stroke – Dhiman et al. (2018) found that at an elevation of 2,000m, the mean age of onset of stroke was 62 years. The age decreased to a mean of 57.9 years at 2,200m in another study (Mahajan et al. (2004)). Yet another study (Razdan et al. (1989)) found 10.9% of the patients in their sample suffered strokes aged < 40, though this was at an altitude of only 1,530m. Some reports suggest higher stroke prevalence at higher altitudes, and at a strikingly young age – between age 20 and age 45.

Student presentation on stroke at altitude at Colorado Medical Society meeting 2022

There have been mixed results on the effect that altitude has on strokes. One systematic review study found 10 studies displaying an increase in stroke prevalence with higher altitude, 5 other studies showing that altitude was actually protective against stroke, and 2 studies in which the results were ambiguous. This study and other sources alluded to the fact that poorer stroke outcomes at higher altitude may be due to polycythemia and increased viscosity of blood. Specifically, Ortiz-Prado et. al noted that “living in high-altitude regions (>2500m) increases the risk of developing thrombosis through hypoxia-driven polycythaemia which leads to a hypercoagulation unbalance”, which was associated with increased risk for stroke. Ortiz-Prado et. al noted that most of their info came from “very few cross-sectional analyses”. These analyses did find “a significant association between living in high-altitude regions and having a greater risk of developing stroke, especially among younger populations”. When the effects of altitude on stroke were broken down by race (Gerken, Huber, Barron, & Zapata, 2022) it was found to be protective in some populations (Whites, African Americans), but detrimental in other populations (Hispanics, Asian-Pacific, and American-Indian). Going back to the work of Ortiz-Prado et. al, altitude increased the risk of stroke at elevations above 3500m, when the time spent at this elevation was at least 28 days, and more so in younger persons (below the age of 45). At lower elevations, between 1500m and 3500m, increased / easier acclimatization and adaptation to hypoxia seemed to offer protective effects against the risk of stroke. Chronic exposure to hypoxia at high altitude triggers adaptive / compensatory mechanisms, such as higher pulmonary arterial flow and improved oxygen diffusing capacity. Ortiz-Prado et. al concluded that a window of ideal elevation seems to exist – below an altitude of 2000m the adaptive mechanisms do not seem to be sufficient to yield a protective effect – however, above 3500m, adaptive mechanisms may actually become maladaptive (excessive polycythemia & blood stasis), yielding a higher risk for stroke. A lack of any adaptation (i.e. in altitude naïve persons) was even more detrimental at such high altitudes, with the authors concluding that “above 3500–4000m, the risk of developing stroke increases, especially if the exposure is acute among non-adapted populations” (Ortiz-Prado et. al, 2022).

Strokes are more common in males compared to females, and this held true at altitudes of 3380m, 4000m, and 4572m. In addition to the standard vascular risk factors such as hypertension, smoking, and diabetes, the higher incidence of polycythemia in persons living at high altitude is thought to play a role. One study (Jha et al. (2002)) found that 75% of the patients in their sample who had suffered strokes had some form of polycythemia – this was at an altitude of 4270m. (Dr. Christine Ebert-Santos of Ebert Family Clinic in Frisco, Colorado at 2743m suspects everyone who lives at altitude has polyerythrocythemia as more accurately described by Dr. Gustavo Zubieta-Calleja of La Paz, Bolivia at 3625m.)

Only about 2% of the world’s population resides at what is considered “high altitude”. Given the current world population (over 8 billion, 5 million), that is still over 160,100,000 people. The sheer number of people that may be at increased risk of stroke is all the more reason for us to act, and act soon, to get more research done. This is further exemplified by the fact that “cerebrovascular events or stroke is the second leading cause of death worldwide, affecting more than 16 million people each year” (Ortiz-Prado et. al). Guidelines need to be implemented to assist in the diagnosis and treatment of stroke at high altitude, to help differentiate it from related conditions such as HACE, giving patients the standard of care that they need and deserve. While a fascinating topic, stroke seems to be delegated to the sidelines in the mountains, cast aside by culprits such as HAPE, HACE, altitude sickness, and hypoxia. More research, more resources, and more funding need to be funneled into understanding stroke at higher altitudes. Overall, it is clear living at or even exposure to higher altitudes can result in a multitude of neurological symptoms, and that a higher incidence of stroke may yet be one of them.

References

Maryam J. Syed, Ismail A. Khatri, Wasim Alamgir, and Mohammad Wasay. Stroke at Moderate and High Altitude. High Altitude Medicine & Biology.Mar 2022.1-7. http://doi.org.mwu.idm.oclc.org/10.1089/ham.2021.0043

Current World Population – https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/ 

Ortiz-Prado E, Cordovez SP, Vasconez E, Viscor G, Roderick P. Chronic high-altitude exposure and the epidemiology of ischaemic stroke: a systematic review. BMJ Open. 2022;12(4):e051777. Published 2022 Apr 29. doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2021-051777

Gerken, Jacob (MS), Huber, Nathan (MS), Barron, Ileana (MD, MPH-S), Zapata, Isain (PhD). “Influence of Elevation of Stroke and Cardiovascular Outcomes”. Poster presented at a conference in Colorado, in 2022.

Links

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9058702/ https://www-liebertpub-com.mwu.idm.oclc.org/doi/full/10.1089/ham.2021.0043

Born in Salt Lake City, Utah, Piotr Poczwardowski has also lived in Upstate New York, Florida, and Colorado (where he spent the 13 years prior to moving to Glendale for PA school). While attending the University of Denver, he volunteered at a nearby hospital Emergency Department, and also participated in a study abroad program in Italy. After earning a degree in Psychology, he worked as both a Primary Care Medical Scribe and Neurology MA. His main hobbies include skiing, watching movies, hiking, swimming, playing video games, reading, and playing ping pong. Piotr has also volunteered at the Sky Ridge Medical Center Emergency Department and secured a job as a Primary Care Medical Scribe after graduating from the University of Denver in 2018. Piotr is now attending Midwestern University’s PA program in Glendale, AZ.

Going Home to the Mountains Can Be Dangerous: Re-Entry HAPE (High Altitude Pulmonary Edema)

Louie was excited to get out on the slopes after spending Thanksgiving with family in Vermont. He got tired early and felt his breathing was harder than usual, leaving early to go home and rest. As a competitive skier he thought that was strange. But he was getting over a cold. He could not have imagined that in 24 hours he would be in the emergency room, fighting for his life.

Louie experienced a dangerous condition, set off by altitude, and inflammation from his “cold”, that caused his lungs to fill with fluid.  His oxygen saturation was 54 % instead of the normal 92, he had been vomiting and feeling very weak and short of breath. His blood tests showed dehydration, hypoxemia and acute kidney injury. His chest x-ray looked like a snowstorm. He was transferred to Children’s Hospital in Denver and admitted to the intensive care unit.

The diagnosis of Re-entry HAPE was confirmed by echocardiogram showing increased pressures in his lungs. He improved rapidly with oxygen and low altitude.

Re-entry HAPE is not rare, affecting several Summit County children every year.  Many do not come to medical attention because after their first episode parents carefully monitor their oxygen and have a concentrator available in their home when they return from travel. 

Medical providers may not be aware of this risk, expecting that children living at altitude are acclimatized. (See previous blog entry on Acclimatization vs. Adaptation, April 17, 2019) Re-entry HAPE seems to occur mostly in children between the ages of 4 and 15. Inflammation, such as a viral respiratory infection, seems to play a role.  Trauma may also predispose a returning resident to Re-entry HAPE, as described in our blog post from February 5, 2018, Re-entry HAPE in High Altitude Residents.

Louie agreed to share his story on our blog to help educate medical personnel and families living in the mountains about this dangerous condition. Further research will help define who is at risk.  The University of Heidelberg recently published an article on the genetics of pulmonary hypertension (HARPE is the New HAPE) and is interested in testing families here who have had more than one person affected by HAPE.