Category Archives: High Altitude Training & Fitness
What are the challenges and benefits of recreation and training in a high altitude environment? How does it affect your body’s physiology? What are the inherent risks?
Health care providers and people who live at altitude often believe that living in the mountains protects from altitude related illness. And yes, there are many ways the body acclimatizes over days, weeks, months, and years, as addressed in previous blog entries. However, as a physician who has practiced in high altitude communities for over 20 years, my personal observation that we are still at risk for serious complications was reenforced by a recent publication by Dr. Santiago Ucrós at the Universidad de los Andes School of Medicine in Santa Fe de Bogotá, Colombia. His article, High altitude pulmonary edema in children: a systemic review, was published in the journal Pediatric Pulmonology in August 2022. He included 35 studies reporting 210 cases, ages 0-18 years, from 12 countries.
Consistent with our experience in Colorado, the most common ages were 6-10 years and second most common 11-15 years. I have not seen or read any reports of adults affected. Cases included two deaths, which I have also seen here.
I receive reports on any of my patients seen in urgent or emergency care. Accidents, avalanches, and suicide attempts are what we think of first needing emergency care in the mountains. However, the most common critical condition is Reentry HAPE. This is a form of pulmonary edema that can occur in children who are returning from a trip to lower altitude. Think visiting Grandma during school break. Dr. Ucrós’ review also confirms that all presentations of HAPE (classic, as in visitors, reentry, and HARPE, resident children with no history of recent travel) are more common in males by a 2.6 to 1 ratio. Analysis of time spent at lower altitude before the episode showed a range of 1.6 to 30 days with a mean of 11.3 days. Mean time between arrival and onset of symptoms for all types of HAPE was 16.7 hours. The minimum altitude change reported in a HAPE case was 520 meters (1700 feet), which is the difference between Frisco, CO (Summit County) and Kremmling, CO (Grand County, the next county over). A new form of HAPE in high altitude residents who travel to higher altitude was designated HL-HAPE in this review. A case report will be featured in an upcoming blog interview with a Summit County resident who traveled to Mt. Kilimanjaro.
As with all cases of HAPE, the victims develop a cough, sound congested as the fluid builds up in their lungs, have fatigue, exercise intolerance, with rapid onset over hours of exposure to altitude, usually above 8000 ft or 2500m. Oxygen saturations in this paper ranged from 55 to 79%. My patients have been as low at 39% in the emergency room. Children presenting earlier or with milder cases come to the office with oxygen saturations in the 80’s. An underlying infection such as a cold or influenza is nearly always present and considered a contributing factor. Everyone living or visiting altitude should have an inexpensive pulse oximeter which can measure oxygen on a finger. Access to oxygen and immediate treatment for values under 89 can be life-saving.
The recurrence rate for all types of HAPE is about 20%. Most children never have another episode, but some have multiple. Preventive measures include slower return to altitude, such as a night in Denver, acetazolamide prescription taken two days before and two days after, and using oxygen for 24-48 hours on arrival. Most families learn to anticipate, prevent, or treat early and don’t need to see a health care provider after the first episode.
On January 26, 2023 I met with Dr. Ucrós and other high altitude scientists including Dr. Christina Eichstaedt, genetics expert at the University of Heidelberg in Germany, Dr. Deborah Liptzen, pediatric pulmonologist, and Dr. Dunbar Ivy, pediatric cardiologist, both from the University of Colorado and Children’s Hospital of Colorado, and Jose Antonio Castro-Rodríguez MD, PhD from the Pontifica Universidad Católica in Santiago de Chile.
We discussed possible genetic susceptibility to HAPE and hypoxia in newborns at altitude with plans to conduct studies in Bogotá and Summit County, Colorado.
Does altitude increase or decrease risk of strokes? As one review put it, “Due to limited literature, lack of large series, and controlled studies, the understanding of stroke at high altitude is still sketchy and incomplete”. What is clear is that stroke at high altitude can often be misdiagnosed (or underdiagnosed), due to the similarity of initial presentation with high altitude cerebral edema (HACE). Both conditions present with imbalance or ataxia, and both can present with focal neurological deficits. There are few large urban populations at high altitude (Addis Ababa in Ethiopia is 7,726 ft), so medical providers have fewer resources. Without the ability to perform neuroimaging with a CT scan or MRI in a timely manner a diagnosis of HACE vs. stroke could be uncertain. HACE often causes global cerebral dysfunction, differentiating it from an early stroke before the onset of focal symptoms can and often does prove challenging.
While the prevalence of strictly hemorrhagic and ischemic strokes at high altitude remains murky, it is known that exposure to high altitude can result in conditions such as TIA, cerebral venous thrombosis (CVT), seizures, and cranial nerve palsies. Most of the research that has been done on strokes is focused on “moderate” and “high” altitudes, as opposed to “very high” or “extremely high” altitudes. As such, there is very little research on populations living at 3500m or higher. There was at least one tangible piece of evidence indicating that the higher the elevation, the earlier the mean onset of stroke – Dhiman et al. (2018) found that at an elevation of 2,000m, the mean age of onset of stroke was 62 years. The age decreased to a mean of 57.9 years at 2,200m in another study (Mahajan et al. (2004)). Yet another study (Razdan et al. (1989)) found 10.9% of the patients in their sample suffered strokes aged < 40, though this was at an altitude of only 1,530m. Some reports suggest higher stroke prevalence at higher altitudes, and at a strikingly young age – between age 20 and age 45.
Student presentation on stroke at altitude at Colorado Medical Society meeting 2022
There have been mixed results on the effect that altitude has on strokes. One systematic review study found 10 studies displaying an increase in stroke prevalence with higher altitude, 5 other studies showing that altitude was actually protective against stroke, and 2 studies in which the results were ambiguous. This study and other sources alluded to the fact that poorer stroke outcomes at higher altitude may be due to polycythemia and increased viscosity of blood. Specifically, Ortiz-Prado et. al noted that “living in high-altitude regions (>2500m) increases the risk of developing thrombosis through hypoxia-driven polycythaemia which leads to a hypercoagulation unbalance”, which was associated with increased risk for stroke. Ortiz-Prado et. al noted that most of their info came from “very few cross-sectional analyses”. These analyses did find “a significant association between living in high-altitude regions and having a greater risk of developing stroke, especially among younger populations”. When the effects of altitude on stroke were broken down by race (Gerken, Huber, Barron, & Zapata, 2022) it was found to be protective in some populations (Whites, African Americans), but detrimental in other populations (Hispanics, Asian-Pacific, and American-Indian). Going back to the work of Ortiz-Prado et. al, altitude increased the risk of stroke at elevations above 3500m, when the time spent at this elevation was at least 28 days, and more so in younger persons (below the age of 45). At lower elevations, between 1500m and 3500m, increased / easier acclimatization and adaptation to hypoxia seemed to offer protective effects against the risk of stroke. Chronic exposure to hypoxia at high altitude triggers adaptive / compensatory mechanisms, such as higher pulmonary arterial flow and improved oxygen diffusing capacity. Ortiz-Prado et. al concluded that a window of ideal elevation seems to exist – below an altitude of 2000m the adaptive mechanisms do not seem to be sufficient to yield a protective effect – however, above 3500m, adaptive mechanisms may actually become maladaptive (excessive polycythemia & blood stasis), yielding a higher risk for stroke. A lack of any adaptation (i.e. in altitude naïve persons) was even more detrimental at such high altitudes, with the authors concluding that “above 3500–4000m, the risk of developing stroke increases, especially if the exposure is acute among non-adapted populations” (Ortiz-Prado et. al, 2022).
Strokes are more common in males compared to females, and this held true at altitudes of 3380m, 4000m, and 4572m. In addition to the standard vascular risk factors such as hypertension, smoking, and diabetes, the higher incidence of polycythemia in persons living at high altitude is thought to play a role. One study (Jha et al. (2002)) found that 75% of the patients in their sample who had suffered strokes had some form of polycythemia – this was at an altitude of 4270m. (Dr. Christine Ebert-Santos of Ebert Family Clinic in Frisco, Colorado at 2743m suspects everyone who lives at altitude has polyerythrocythemia as more accurately described by Dr. Gustavo Zubieta-Calleja of La Paz, Bolivia at 3625m.)
Only about 2% of the world’s population resides at what is considered “high altitude”. Given the current world population (over 8 billion, 5 million), that is still over 160,100,000 people. The sheer number of people that may be at increased risk of stroke is all the more reason for us to act, and act soon, to get more research done. This is further exemplified by the fact that “cerebrovascular events or stroke is the second leading cause of death worldwide, affecting more than 16 million people each year” (Ortiz-Prado et. al). Guidelines need to be implemented to assist in the diagnosis and treatment of stroke at high altitude, to help differentiate it from related conditions such as HACE, giving patients the standard of care that they need and deserve. While a fascinating topic, stroke seems to be delegated to the sidelines in the mountains, cast aside by culprits such as HAPE, HACE, altitude sickness, and hypoxia. More research, more resources, and more funding need to be funneled into understanding stroke at higher altitudes. Overall, it is clear living at or even exposure to higher altitudes can result in a multitude of neurological symptoms, and that a higher incidence of stroke may yet be one of them.
Ortiz-Prado E, Cordovez SP, Vasconez E, Viscor G, Roderick P. Chronic high-altitude exposure and the epidemiology of ischaemic stroke: a systematic review. BMJ Open. 2022;12(4):e051777. Published 2022 Apr 29. doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2021-051777
Gerken, Jacob (MS), Huber, Nathan (MS), Barron, Ileana (MD, MPH-S), Zapata, Isain (PhD). “Influence of Elevation of Stroke and Cardiovascular Outcomes”. Poster presented at a conference in Colorado, in 2022.
Born in Salt Lake City, Utah, Piotr Poczwardowski has also lived in Upstate New York, Florida, and Colorado (where he spent the 13 years prior to moving to Glendale for PA school). While attending the University of Denver, he volunteered at a nearby hospital Emergency Department, and also participated in a study abroad program in Italy. After earning a degree in Psychology, he worked as both a Primary Care Medical Scribe and Neurology MA. His main hobbies include skiing, watching movies, hiking, swimming, playing video games, reading, and playing ping pong.Piotr has also volunteered at the Sky Ridge Medical Center Emergency Department and secured a job as a Primary Care Medical Scribe after graduating from the University of Denver in 2018. Piotr is now attending Midwestern University’s PA program in Glendale, AZ.
Louie was excited to get out on the slopes after spending Thanksgiving with family in Vermont. He got tired early and felt his breathing was harder than usual, leaving early to go home and rest. As a competitive skier he thought that was strange. But he was getting over a cold. He could not have imagined that in 24 hours he would be in the emergency room, fighting for his life.
Louie experienced a dangerous condition, set off by altitude, and inflammation from his “cold”, that caused his lungs to fill with fluid. His oxygen saturation was 54 % instead of the normal 92, he had been vomiting and feeling very weak and short of breath. His blood tests showed dehydration, hypoxemia and acute kidney injury. His chest x-ray looked like a snowstorm. He was transferred to Children’s Hospital in Denver and admitted to the intensive care unit.
The diagnosis of Re-entry HAPE was confirmed by echocardiogram showing increased pressures in his lungs. He improved rapidly with oxygen and low altitude.
Re-entry HAPE is not rare, affecting several Summit County children every year. Many do not come to medical attention because after their first episode parents carefully monitor their oxygen and have a concentrator available in their home when they return from travel.
Medical providers may not be aware of this risk, expecting that children living at altitude are acclimatized. (See previous blog entry on Acclimatization vs. Adaptation, April 17, 2019) Re-entry HAPE seems to occur mostly in children between the ages of 4 and 15. Inflammation, such as a viral respiratory infection, seems to play a role. Trauma may also predispose a returning resident to Re-entry HAPE, as described in our blog post from February 5, 2018, Re-entry HAPE in High Altitude Residents.
Louie agreed to share his story on our blog to help educate medical personnel and families living in the mountains about this dangerous condition. Further research will help define who is at risk. The University of Heidelberg recently published an article on the genetics of pulmonary hypertension (HARPE is the New HAPE) and is interested in testing families here who have had more than one person affected by HAPE.
HAPE can affect long term locals too. There is no specific test to diagnosis HAPE leading to delayed treatment or improper treatment, including death.
HAPE is defined as fluid accumulation in the lungs when an individual spends about 48 hours at elevations of 8,200 feet or higher. This can occur when 1) tourists who are not accumulated to high altitudes appropriately 2) locals who re-enter high altitude after being at lower elevation for a period of time or 3) long term residents who develop an illness.
What are the signs and symptoms you ask? Exhaustion, dyspnea on exertion, productive cough, tachypnea, tachycardia, low oxygen saturation levels, and crackles upon lung assessments are the most common to be seen. These are very generic symptoms and resemble many other diseases, such as pneumonia and asthma, leading to misdiagnosis and improper treatment.
How is HAPE treated?
The answer is simple, oxygen. The body is being deprived of oxygen and is unable to feed our cells. By giving oxygen (either through an artificial source or returning to lower elevation) and allowing the body to rest, the body is able to meet its demand for oxygen and symptoms resolve. If one receives oxygen and symptoms do not improve, there is most likely an underlying cause that is contributing to the symptoms unrelated to HAPE.
A pulse oximeter is the easiest way that one can monitor their oxygen levels at home. This device can be purchased over the counter, relatively inexpensive, and easy to use. By placing the pulse oximeter on one’s finger, the device will read the individual’s oxygen level which should be greater than 90% (when at altitude). The heart rate will also be recorded which tends to be between 60-100 beats per minute when at rest for adults.
References
A new mechanism to prevent pulmonary edema in severe infections. Lung Disease News. (n.d.). Retrieved September 2, 2022, from https://lungdiseasenews.com/2015/01/14/researchers-discover-a-new-mechanism-to-prevent-pulmonary-edema-in-severe-infections/
Bhattarai, A., Acharya, S., Yadav, J. K., & Wilkes, M. (2019). Delayed-onset high altitude pulmonary edema: A case report. Wilderness & Environmental Medicine, 30(1), 90–92. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wem.2018.11.002
Fixler, K. (2017, October 12). Colorado doctor: Health effects of living in mountains unknown to medical establishment. SummitDaily.com. Retrieved September 2, 2022, from https://www.summitdaily.com/news/summit-county-doctor-makes-a-case-for-high-altitude-disorder-that-affects-even-the-acclimated/
I had the honor of interviewing Andrew Breithaupt who recently retired from US Customs and Border Protection in the Department of Homeland Security where he served as an Air Interdiction Agent piloting multiple types of aircraft. He currently serves as a Lieutenant Colonel on active duty for the US Army, stationed in Minneapolis, MN. He began Army flight school in 1992 to become a helicopter pilot, ultimately qualifying in 4 different types of Army helicopters including the UH-1H, OH-58, AH-1, and the AH-64 Apache for which he became an Instructor Pilot training new Army aviators at Fort Rucker, Alabama. Later he began his transition to fixed-wing aircraft in the civilian community. After nearly 10 years of Army active duty and multiple overseas tours, he was selected to enter service for US Customs and Border Protection where he served as a federal law enforcement agent for over 20 years, retired in December of 2021. He holds his commercial pilot license for single engine & multi-engine fixed wing as well as rotorcraft with instrument privileges and aircraft type ratings. He has over 30 years of aviation experience and more than 2,500 hours of flight time over his career. I sat down to chat with him about his accomplished career and learn more about his aviation and altitude expertise.
In army flight school, specifically aeromedical training, he was taught the effects of aviation on the body. One of the first lessons they learned in their training was how to recognize the early warning signs of hypoxia. These include shortness of breath, dysphoria, nausea, vomiting and lightheadedness. This type of training is often done in altitude chambers, so trainees can experience these effects before they are in the air, including how aviation can affect your vestibular senses. A position change as simple as looking down to change a radio or instrument can completely disorient a pilot due to the change in direction of the fluid within the inner ear against the cilia. This can lead to the sensation that the plane has rotated and flying sideways. They are taught to trust their instruments because an overcorrection can lead to what they teach in flight school as a “death spiral.” The training is often done in a Barany Chair and simulates vestibular senses experienced during flight.
Elevation in Summit County, Colorado ranges from 7,947 feet to 14,270 feet, the highest peak being Gray’s Peak. With people living as high as 11,200 feet, as Andrew does at his home in Blue River located south of of Breckenridge, CO. Andrew shared some very interesting aviation altitude requirements which might surprise some. He spent much of his career operating non-pressurized helicopters and Federal Aviation Regulations prohibited him from going between 10,000 feet to 12,000 feet for more than 30 minutes without oxygen. When flying above 12,000 feet, pilots are required to have supplemental oxygen regardless of the amount of time spent at that elevation depending on the category of aviation being conducted such as commercial operations. This is according to the CFR (Code of Federal Regulations) Part 135 which governs commercial aircraft operations. How interesting is it that pilots have these regulations, yet many people who live in Summit County or those summiting 14ers (peaks at 14,000 ft. or above) are at or above these elevations with no supplemental oxygen on a daily basis. When flying private aircraft, CFR part 91.211 specifies flight crew can fly without pressurization or supplemental O2 below 14,000 feet and passengers below 15,000 feet.
While in the Army, Andrew would rarely operate aircraft above 8,000 feet and would typically not have supplemental oxygen on board. They were trained to begin descent immediately if they were to notice the early signs of hypoxia. Keeping a pilot’s license requires strict annual or even semi-annual FAA physicals and continued training to ensure their bodies can withstand the effects of aviation. As you can imagine those holding these licenses are some of the most fit men and women in the country. Andrew rarely felt the effects of altitude even with altitude changes as great as 8,000 feet coming from sea level. He would typically remain at these elevations for two hours or less piloting non-pressurized aircraft.
To give some perspective, when you hop on a commercial flight for your next adventure these planes typically fly around 28,000 to 36,000 feet of elevation. When beginning the ascent, the aircraft pressure stabilizes at 6,000 to 8,000 feet, approximately when the dreaded “popping of the ears” is felt. Supplemental oxygen and quick donning masks are required on all these aircraft in case depressurization were to occur due to the rapid hypoxia which would occur at such high altitudes.
Andrew moved to Summit County in November of 2021 from Stafford, VA with his wife and five sons ages 24, 22, 19, 14, and 11. Andrew and his family spent a significant amount of time in Summit County for snowboarding and skiing competitions and quickly fell in love with the area prior to spending the last 5 years living in Stuttgart, Germany. This is when they decided one day, they would become full-time residents of the county. They moved here for the “people, climate and lifestyle,” a combination I am learning is hard to beat outside of Summit County. With ski and snowboard season right around the corner, he and his family are excited to get back out on the slopes. Andrew currently travels between his home in Blue River and Minneapolis for his position in the Army. With each trip back he feels his body more quickly adjust to the altitude changes. Thank you for your service Andrew, and welcome to the community!
Ellie Martini grew up in Richmond, VA and is currently a second-year Physician Assistant student at Drexel University in Philadelphia, PA. She completed her undergraduate degree at The College of William and Mary in Williamsburg, VA where she received her BS in Biology. Before PA school she worked as a rehab tech and medical scribe at an addiction clinic. In her free time she enjoys hiking, biking, group fitness, traveling and spending time with friends and family.
From backpacking and camping to skiing and snowboarding, there are plenty of activities outdoors in the Colorado high country. If you find yourself wandering around and lost without food in the mountains, there are several wild plants that you can eat.
However, before you consume the delectable greens, there are a few precautions to take.
Moose shopping
Do not eat any wild plants unless you can positively identify them. There are iOS and Android apps that you can download prior to your hike to help distinguish plants, such as PictureThis and NatureID.
Be aware of environmental factors such as pollution or animal waste. Avoid popular wild animal gathering areas.
Make sure you’re not allergic to the plant by rubbing it against your skin and observing for a reaction. If so, do not eat the plant. Before ingesting a large quantity, eat a small amount and check for a reaction.
It may be difficult to cook if you did not come prepared with a portable stove, pots, and water, which could limit ways to enjoy vegetation. Here is a list of edible plants, how to identify them, where can they be found, and which part you can eat.
Wild plants
Dandelions (Taraxacum officinale): yellow ray florets that spread outward from center with toothy, deep-notched, hairless basal leaves and hollow stems. They can be found everywhere and anywhere. Every part of the dandelion plant is edible including the leaves and roots.
Pineapple Weed/ Wild Chamomile (Matricaria discoidea): the flower heads are cone-shaped and yellowish-green and do not have petals. Often found near walking paths and roadsides, harvest away from disturbed, polluted areas. If you’re feeling anxious about being lost, pineapple weed promotes relaxation and sleep and serves as a digestive aid.
Fireweed (Epilobium angustifolium): vibrant fuchsia flowers. Grows in disturbed areas and near recent burn zones. Eat the leaves when they are young as adult leaves can stupefy you. Young shoot tips and roots are also edible.
Wild onions (Allium cernuum): look for pink, lavender to white flowers with a strong scent of onion. They grow in the subalpine terrain and are found on moist hillsides and meadows. Caution: do not confuse with death camas. If it doesn’t smell like an onion and has pink flowers, it is not likely an onion.
Cattails (Typha latifolia or Typha angustifolia): typically 5-10 feet tall. Mature flower stalks resemble the tail of a cat. Grow by creek, river, ponds, and lakes. This whole plant is edible, from the top to the roots. Select from pollution-free areas as it is known to absorb toxins in the surrounding water.
Wild berries:
Wild strawberries (Fragaria virginiana): they are tiny compared to store-bought. Can be identified by their blue-green leaves; small cluster of white flowers with a yellow center; and slightly hairy, long and slender red stems.
Huckleberries (Vaccinium spp): They grow in the high mountain acidic soil and flourish in the forest grounds underneath small, oval-shaped, pointed leaves. They resemble blueberries and have a distinguishable “crown” structure at the bottom of the berry. They can be red, maroon, dark blue, powder-blue, or purple-blue to almost black, and they range from translucent to opaque.
Oregon grapes (Mahonia aquifolium): powder-blue berries, resembling juniper berries or blueberries, with spiny leaves similar to hollies that may have reddish tints.
Fun fact: The roots and bark of the plant contain a compound called berberine. Berberine has antimicrobial, antiviral, antifungal, and antibiotic properties.
Mushrooms
True morels (Morchella spp.): cone-shaped top with lots of deep crevices resembling a sponge. They will be hollow inside. A false morel will have a similar appearance on the outside but will not be hollow on the inside and are toxic. Morels are commonly found at the edge of forested areas where ash, aspen, elm, and oak trees live. Dead trees (forest wildfires) and old apple orchards are prime spots for morels.
Porcini (Boletus edulis): brown-capped mushrooms with thick, white stalks. Found at high elevations of 10,500 and 11,200 ft in areas with monsoon rains and sustained summer heat.
There are many more edible plants, flowers, berries, and mushrooms in the mountains. These are just 10 that can be easily identifiable and common in the Western Colorado landscapes. I recommend trying out the apps listed above and reading “Wild Edible Plants of Colorado” by Charles W. Kane, which includes 58 plants from various regions, each with details of use and preparation. Hopefully this post made you feel more prepared for your next adventure.
Resources:
Davis, E., 2022. Fall plant tour: Frisco, CO | Wild Food Girl. [online] Wildfoodgirl.com. Available at: <https://wildfoodgirl.com/2012/eleven-edible-wild-plants-from-frisco-trailhead/> [Accessed 10 July 2022].
McGuire, P., 2022. 8 Delicious Foods to Forage in Colorado | Wild Berries…. [online] Uncovercolorado.com. Available at: <https://www.uncovercolorado.com/foraging-for-food-in-colorado/> [Accessed 10 July2022].
Rmhp.org. 2022. Edible Plants On The Western Slope | RMHP Blog. [online] Available at: <https://www.rmhp.org/blog/2020/march/foraging-for-edible-plants> [Accessed 10 July 2022].
Lifescapecolorado.com. 2022. [online] Available at: <https://lifescapecolorado.com/2014/01/edible-plants-of-colorado/> [Accessed 10 July 2022].
Pfaf.org. 2022. Plant Search Result. [online] Available at: <https://pfaf.org/user/DatabaseSearhResult.aspx> [Accessed 10 July 2022].
Cindy Hinh is a second-year Physician Assistant student at Red Rocks Community College in Arvada, CO. She grew up in southern Louisiana and received her undergraduate degree in Biology from Louisiana State University. Prior to PA school, she was a medical scribe in the emergency department and an urgent care tech. In her free time, she enjoys baking, cooking, going on food adventures, hiking, and spending time with family and friends.
Eighteen-year-old, NorAm skier, NCAA Division I Rugby player, and lover of the outdoors, presents to the clinic complaining of cold, painful hands. She states hands always feel cold, and in cold weather they are extremely painful. Blood tests to rule out vascular disease were normal. What could be the cause of this?
Normally, in cold weather our bodies work to keep essential organs functioning. Skin is not considered essential. When exposed to cold, blood vessels constrict, decreasing blood flow to the skin. Because the metabolic demand of our skin is low, more important organs like our heart and brain need the blood flow. Paradoxically, exposure to cooler temperatures like those below 15 degrees Celsius or 59 degrees Fahrenheit can cause cold-induced vasodilation. This allows blood to flow to the skin to help prevent more serious injury or frostbite. The vasodilation cycles in 5- to 10-minute intervals.
Nonfreezing cold injury (NFCI) occurs when tissues are damaged due to prolonged cooling exposure, but not freezing temperatures. NFCI is due to exposure of the extremities to temperatures around 0 to 15°C or 32 to 59°F, commonly the hands and feet. Current theory is that NFCI is due to a combination of vascular and neural dysfunction. With prolonged vasoconstriction, the skin experiences reduced blood flow with a neurological component influencing the damage as well.
Some patients living in cold environments like the Inuit, Sami people, and Nordic fisherman have a larger cold-induced vasodilation response and more rapid cycling. This is thought to decrease their risk of NFCI. Is it possible that patients who develop NFCI have a smaller and slower cycling of their cold-induced vasodilation? Could this be the issue with our patient with NFCI? Further research is needed to learn more about NFCI and find better ways to treat it.
What we do know is there are 4 Stages of NFCI:
Stage 1: During the cold exposure – Loss of sensation, numbness, clumsiness. Usually painless unless rewarming is attempted.
Stage 2: Following cold exposure – occurs during and after rewarming. Skin can develop a mottled pale blue-like color, area continues to feel cold and numb, possible swelling. Usually lasts a few hours to several days.
Stage 3: Hyperemia – affected area becomes red and painful. Begins suddenly and lasts for several days to weeks.
Stage 4: Following hyperemia – affected areas appear normal but are hypersensitive to the cold. Areas may remain cold even after short exposure to the cold. This stage can last for weeks to years.
Outdoor paddle sports like kayaking and canoeing put patients at greatest risk due to the continual exposure to the cold, wet environment. It was thought that in order to have NFCI, one had to be exposed to both cold and wet environments. However, it has been shown that this is not always the case. Like in our patient, exposure to just cold environment can trigger the syndrome. Our 18-year-old patient is an avid skier and spends most of the winter on the mountain. It was also noted that she enjoys paddleboarding and kayaking, which were recognized as triggers for the hand pain. We are unable to determine exactly what caused our patient to develop this syndrome. But we do know it affects their life significantly.
We choose to live in the mountains because of the things we love. Whether it is hiking, biking, skiing, kayaking, paddleboarding, or the hundreds of other activities offered in this area, we are at risk of NFCI. Currently, there is no good treatment for this syndrome. Prevention is best. The purpose of this blog is to share information about staying healthy at high altitude. Sharing this information on the stages of NFCI with friends and family will help prevent this painful, debilitating syndrome.
Resources
Nonfreezing cold water (trench foot) and warm water immersion injuries. UpToDate. https://www.uptodate.com/contents/nonfreezing-cold-water-trench-foot-and-warm-water-immersion-injuries/print#:~:text=Nonfreezing%20cold%20injury%20%E2%80%94%20NFCI%20is,to%2059%C2%B0F)%20conditions. Accessed July 14, 2022.
Oakley B, Brown HL, Johnson N, Bainbridge C. Nonfreezing cold injury and cold intolerance in Paddlesport. Wilderness & Environmental Medicine. 2022;33(2):187-196. doi:10.1016/j.wem.2022.03.003
Rachel Cole is a Physician Assistant Student at Red Rocks Community College in Denver, Colorado. She originally grew up in Salt Lake City, Utah, where she learned to love the outdoors. She studied Biology at Western Colorado University in Gunnison, Colorado prior to PA school. She played soccer for the college and fell in love with Colorado and small mountain towns. When she is not studying for school, she enjoys skiing, hiking, backpacking, fishing, waterskiing, canyoneering, and any other activities that get her outside. After graduation she hopes to practice family medicine in a rural community in the mountains.
Have you thought of what it would be like living in the mountains year-round? Medical professionals find it is important to look at what living at high elevations can do to the human body. One activity heavily affected is sleep. As mentioned in previous blog posts, visitors often have trouble falling asleep, staying asleep, and feeling rested in the morning. A recent study published in Physiological Reports measured the effects of sleeping patterns at high elevation. The participants experienced a simulated elevation inside a hyperbaric chamber. This mimicked sleeping at elevations of 3000 meters (9,842 feet) and 4050 meters (13,287 ft) for one night and then sleeping at sea level for several nights to establish a baseline for the research participants. Participants exercised for 3 hours in the hyperbaric chamber allowing researchers to observe how the lower oxygen concentrations affected their ability to perform strenuous tasks. The group that slept in a simulated 4050 meter environment had an increased heart rate that was 28% higher and an oxygen saturation 15% lower than the 3000 meter participants. When comparing sleep itself, the group at 4050 meters had 50% more awakening events throughout each night. This goes along with previous research on this blog that states that people who sleep at high altitude complain of insomnia and frequent awakening when first arriving at high elevation.
These numbers increase even more dramatically when compared to participants at sea level. Related symptoms reported during this study showed the incidence of acute mountain sickness occurred in 10% of the participants at a simulated 3000 meters, increasing to 90% at 4050 meters. As mentioned, the average heart rate increases and oxygen saturation decreases as the elevation increases. The baseline heart rate at sea level was 62 beats per minute, increasing to 80 at 3000 meters and 93 at 4050 meters. Ideally health care providers aim to oxygenate vital organs by keeping the oxygen saturation level between 92-100%. The lower the oxygen level the harder it is to keep organs properly profused. Age, health status, and place of residence are taken into consideration when examining study reports. Oxygen saturation at sea level was 98% decreasing to 92% at 3000 meters and 84% at 4050 meters.
As mentioned in a previous post by Dr. Neale Lange, sleeping at high altitudes can be hard due to the frequent awakenings and nocturnal hypoxia caused by the low oxygen levels at higher elevation. This study reiterates these findings with the results of the average oxygen saturation at 3000 meters being around 92%. Dr. Lange also found that sleep apnea was often more prominent and had more negative effects on the human body in environments that were lower in oxygen. This study agrees with that statement finding that people with sleep apnea had twice the hourly awakenings compared to those at higher elevation that did not have sleep apnea. Dr. Lange also pointed out that the contribution of hypobaric atmosphere to symptoms at altitude as opposed to pure hypoxemia is unknown. Frisco, Colorado is at an elevation of 2800 meters. Ongoing research at Ebert Family Clinic including residents and visitors along with laboratory studies such as this one can guide decisions about interventions and treatment to improve sleep and help us enjoy our time in the mountains.
References
Figueiredo PS, Sils IV, Staab JE, Fulco CS, Muza SR, Beidleman BA. Acute mountain sickness and sleep disturbances differentially influence cognition and mood during rapid ascent to 3000 and 4050 m. Physiological Reports. 2022;10(3). doi:10.14814/phy2.15175
Blog post: HOW DO YOU DEFINE A GOOD NIGHT’S SLEEP?:AN INTRODUCTION TO THE SLEEPIMAGE RING, AN INTERVIEW WITH DR. NEALE LANGE
Casey Weibel is a 2nd year student at Drexel University, born and raised in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. He went to Gannon University for his undergrad and got a degree in biology. Before PA school, Casey was an EMT. He enjoys hiking and kayaking and is a big sports fan.
Wild animals, storms, avalanches, cold, high altitude pulmonary edema or cerebral edema, falls, fires and injuries are the most common dangers in the mountains. I’ve climbed 19 different mountains in Colorado over 14,000′, and some of them more than once, making for 28 successful ascents. But I called Summit County Search and Rescue Saturday for something I was not expecting: deep wet snow that trapped me less than 2 miles from the trailhead.
Summit County trail map
It was a bright, warm day — I had even left my hand warmers at home. My plan was to hike from Miners Creek trailhead in Frisco to Gold Hill Trailhead north of Breckenridge which is about a 6- or 7-mile trip one way. I had hiked from both ends in previous weeks and saw the turn-off had snow and no tracks. I attached my snowshoes to my backpack with plans to turn up towards Gold Hill if there were tracks, and there were.
After 4 miles I was out of the forest on top with gorgeous 360˚ views of mountains. I no longer saw the trail markers or tracks so set out across the open space with my snowshoes sinking into the snow every 10 to 20 feet. The trail maps and GPS on my phone were sketchy, only showing I was very near the Colorado Trail. I turned down a logging road to get out of the wind thinking the snow would be packed. I could see several open areas that I thought would take me to the familiar trails to Gold Hill.
After an hour sinking into deep snow I noticed I had only one snowshoe. I backtracked 100 feet following the tracks to find it, dug at several spots where I had sunk the deepest but never found it. I went back towards the Colorado Trail but could not progress, having to dig my boot out of deep snow several times. I tried to backtrack in my footsteps but couldn’t get far. I had now covered a mile in an hour and a half, my phone showing I was only 48 minutes from the Gold Hill trailhead.
So I called 911, thinking they could drive a snowmobile up to get me. Bad news: the vehicle would just sink the same way I was. The 911 operator knew me and the Summit County Search & Rescue mission coordinator Mark Svenson was in touch several times as I waited from 3:17 until about 6 pm when the crew arrived with skis and extra snowshoes. My Blue Heeler Isa and I stayed within one foot of a small pine tree where we found firm footing after rolling through the deep, soft snow. Luckily the sun kept us warm until 5 pm, and I had food and water. My gloves and boots were soaked so my feet were very cold and I tried to keep Isa lying over my legs or feet. I had a plastic rain shield extension that I could pull out and sit on in a pocket of the backpack that one of my students had gifted me.
The rescuers had water, snacks, dry socks, dry gloves, gators and snowshoes. They had packed down the trail but there were still times we post-holed on the way down. We arrived at the rescue vehicle as darkness fell. Special Operations Sheriff SJ Hamit waited with Mark and other SCSR staff to welcome us. One of the rescuers told me how happy he was that I was still smiling when they arrived!
Summit County Search & Rescue team, Sheriff Hamit on the left, Dr. Chris far right.
What did I learn? Stay out of deep, wet snow even if it means going back the long way. Bring extra socks and gloves. Buy gators.
I was not afraid because I knew they were coming before dark. I do feel exhilarated that I was able to do such a challenging hike without any pain or blisters, that my knees were strong enough to extract my feet from the deep snow so many times, and that Isa was with me to warn if any animals were near and announce when the rescuers arrived.
Christine Ebert-Santos, MD, MPS is the founding physician and president of Ebert Family Clinic in Frisco, Colorado, where she leads high altitude research in addition to running a full-time family practice. Isa is a two-year-old blue heeler and Dr. Chris’s familiar and guardian angel.
After his father-in-law arrived in the mountains, Thomas noticed later that night he seemed intoxicated despite not seeing him drink alcohol. Thomas woke up the next morning to see him reading the paper in nothing but black socks and a black tie. Thomas knew right away he wasn’t drunk, he had high altitude cerebral edema (HACE). HACE is a complication of acute mountain sickness (AMS). HACE can occur from increased pressure in the blood vessels in the brain, leading to fluid leakage and swelling (edema). This increased vessel pressure can result from the lower atmospheric pressure at high altitude1. Breathing in lower atmospheric pressure gives you less oxygen molecules per breath. Thomas estimates that EMS in Summit County see one case of HACE a year. EMS look for two hallmark signs of HACE, altered mentation and ataxia. When EMS arrive to a patient with altered mentation, they have the patient walk heel-to-toe to evaluate for ataxia. If ataxia is present, immediate descent is necessary. Rapid descent is necessary because HACE can progress rapidly. Years ago, Thomas had a patient walk into the emergency department and die within 10 minutes after arrival. Unlike high altitude pulmonary edema (HAPE), descent is the only cure for HACE.
HAPE is a more common complication of AMS. Similar to HACE, edema occurs from the high pressure inside pulmonary blood vessels pushing fluid into the lungs. The high pressure is caused by a rapid vasoconstriction response to hypoxia or low oxygen partial pressures. Luckily, HAPE has a simple treatment, oxygen. Therefore, visitors with HAPE do not need to descend to lower altitude as with HACE. HAPE is much harder to recognize than HACE and EMS is well trained in how to recognize it. Often, headache is the only symptom2. Thomas explains the HAPE protocol for EMS: In the first 20 seconds of arriving, an oxygen saturation is obtained; they obtain vitals in the next two minutes and then start high flow oxygen if the saturation is below 89%; they then listen to the lungs for signs of fluid. EMS does not treat HACE or HAPE with any medications since descent and oxygen are the effective treatments.
So, who is prone to AMS?
Unfortunately, better physical fitness does not protect you from AMS. Thomas reports that athletes with resting heart rates of 40 or below have a difficult time acclimating. Younger age also doesn’t mean easier acclimation. According to Thomas, the best age for acclimation is late 30s/early 40s. Surprisingly, previous hypoxia can help acclimation to high altitude. For example, Thomas reports that smokers have an easier time acclimating because their body is used to having the vasoconstriction response to hypoxia and breathing faster and deeper to get adequate oxygen intake.
But don’t worry, your conditioning wasn’t for nothing. A healthy diet and regular exercise prevents heart disease. Thomas estimates there are about 12 acute MI’s on the ski hill each year. These patients usually have to be transported to Denver for a stent to be placed. Exacerbation of coronary artery disease (CAD) is so common that EMS refers to altitude travel as the “altitude stress test.” This mimics a cardiac stress test in those with CAD, producing chest pain that wasn’t present at lower altitude.
Those with sickle cell disease are at risk of developing sickle cell crisis when traveling to high altitude. The lower atmospheric pressure allows the normal red blood cells to lose their integrity and become sickle. Thomas reports that EMS encounters this every couple months in patients (usually of Mediterranean descent) that present with diffuse abdominal pain with no obvious cause. This pain results from the sickle cells aggregating together and causing an occlusion. The occlusion leads to tissue hypoxia and ischemia3. These patients are transported to the hospital for treatment.
How can mountain tourists avoid AMS?
Thomas’s first recommendation is to take a staggered stop for one night at an elevation of 5,000-6,000ft, like Denver. When arriving to altitude, take it easy the first 3 days: don’t drink alcohol and do light activity. Save the long hike for the end of the trip. Also avoid substances that blunt the respiratory system like alcohol, opioids, benzodiazepines, etc. Prepare by hydrating the week before and keep drinking plenty of water while on the trip. If you have had a previous episode of AMS, you can speak to your medical provider about prophylactic medication to take before arriving at high altitude.
2. Schafermeyer, R. W. DynaMed. Acute Altitude Illnesses. EBSCO Information Services. https://www.dynamed.com/condition/acute-altitude-illnesses. Accessed November 19, 2021.
3. Sheehan VA, Gordeuk VR, Kutlar A. Disorders of Hemoglobin Structure: Sickle Cell Anemia and Related Abnormalities. In: Kaushansky K, Prchal JT, Burns LJ, Lichtman MA, Levi M, Linch DC. eds. Williams Hematology, 10e. McGraw Hill; 2021. Accessed November 23, 2021. https://accessmedicine-mhmedical-com.ezproxy2.library.drexel.edu/content.aspx?bookid=2962§ionid=252529206
Samantha Fredrickson is currently a student in Drexel University’s Physician Assistant program.
